Corporation
The corporation is the best known business form. Most big companies
that are "household names" are corporations, including companies like
Google Inc., Microsoft Corp., and Yahoo! Inc. A corporation has a legal
identity that is separate from its owners (usually referred to as
"shareholders" or "stockholders"). Although many corporations are large
organizations with many employees, it is possible for a single person
to form and operate a corporation individually.
Operating as a corporation offers limited liability
to shareholders, transferability of ownership interests (shares), and
perpetual existence of the corporation, even after original
shareholders have left the business. Because most successful, big-name
companies are corporations, many believe that operating as a
corporation must be advantageous, but this is not always true. In fact, however, corporations often have disadvantages, including "double taxation" and the cost and hassle associated with forming and operating a corporation. Because of these disadvantages, in many cases an LLC
will be a better choice for a small citizen media business with owners
who are concerned about liability exposure. In fact, unless you plan on
taking your business "public" (i.e., selling shares of the company to
the general public) in the near future, or you are working with venture
capitalists who require you to form a corporation, there generally are
few reasons to operate your small business as a corporation.
A few technical points are worth mentioning up front. First,
when we mention a "corporation" in this guide, we mean a "C
corporation" unless we specify otherwise. Probably all of the big
companies you think of as "corporations" are C corporations. There is
another type of corporation, however, called an "S corporation," which
we discuss briefly on the S Corporation
page. The important difference between the two is how they are treated
for tax purposes. While S corporations are generally not subject to "double
taxation" like C corporations, they still require most, if not all, of
the costly and burdensome formalities associated with C corporations,
and they offer no significant benefits over LLCs. Second, certain
states recognize what is known as a "close corporation," which we
discuss briefly on the Close Corporation
page. This business form generally allows for greater flexibility and
informality in managing business affairs than a C corporation, but it
requires creation of a shareholders' agreement and significant
limitations on transfer of stock, and LLCs are generally regarded as
superior vehicles for obtaining an informal, de-centralized management
structure with limited liability.
In determining whether you want to operate as a corporation, you may want to consider the following factors:
- Liability: Shareholders of a corporation enjoy limited liability for the debts and obligations of the business, including liability for the unlawful acts of other shareholders and employees.
For instance, if a fellow shareholder writes a defamatory article or
posts copyright infringing material on your jointly-run website or
blog, then your liability ordinarily is limited to amounts invested in
the corporation. The same goes for a defamatory article or infringing
post published by an employee on the company's site. However, limited
liability does not relieve you from personal liability for your own unlawful actions.
-
- Corporations, like LLCs, are subject to the legal doctrine known as "piercing the corporate veil," which can result in shareholders losing limited liability protection in extremely rare circumstances.
- If you apply for a small business loan, the lender probably
will require you to give a personal guarantee. In that case, you are
personally responsible for the paying back the debt, even if the
business is a corporation and even if there is no basis for piercing
the corporate veil.
- Formation: Forming a corporation is moderate in terms of burden and cost. Please see the Forming a Corporation
section for details on the required steps. The steps are usually
carried out by the initial owners of the corporation (called
"incorporators" in legal terminology), although owners can hire others
to do it for them. Corporations are governed by state law, and formation requires filing articles of incorporation
with a state office, usually the Secretary of State. Creating and
submitting articles of incorporation is simple and generally does not
require the assistance of a lawyer, but there usually are significant
filing fees. It also requires creation of corporate bylaws,
which are internal rules and procedures regarding the operation of the
corporation that are stored at the corporation's place of business but
not filed with the state. Drafting bylaws that are highly customized to
your business may involve some complexity. It will be up to you and
your fellow shareholders whether the assistance of a lawyer is
required.
-
- Forming a corporation is slightly more burdensome than
forming an LLC. One difference is that the owners of a newly formed
corporation should hold an initial organizational meeting to adopt
bylaws, elect initial directors (if not named in the articles of incorporation),
and authorize the issuance of stock to themselves, among other things.
Minutes of this meeting must be recorded. Another difference is that
stock must be issued, and this requires creation of formal stock
certificates and a stock ledger for record-keeping purposes. Neither of
these steps are required to form an LLC.
- Management Structure: Corporations are centrally managed
by a board of directors, which is charged with making major strategic
and financial decisions for the company and ensuring compliance with
relevant legal and accounting requirements. The board of directors
meets and makes decisions collectively. State corporate laws and
corporate bylaws generally set out voting requirements for valid board action, such as how many directors are needed to constitute a quorum
and whether action in writing without a formal meeting is permitted.
The full panoply of issues relating to a properly functioning board of
directors is beyond the scope of this Guide.
-
- The board of directors nominates the officers of the
corporation to run the day-to-day affairs of the company and oversee
the activities of employees (if any). Common examples of corporate
officers include president, vice president, secretary, and chief
financial officer. Effective day-to-day control of the business will be
in the hand of these officers.
- Note that, if a corporation has single shareholder, state
laws allow that shareholder to occupy the role of sole director and
sole officer, all at once.
- In some states, shareholders can opt out of the centralized management structure by forming a close corporation,
but there are significant disadvantages to forming a close corporation,
and owners often choose to form an LLC instead. Please see the Close Corporation section for details.
- Operation: Operating a corporation is moderately
burdensome and costly, somewhat more so than operating an LLC. State
corporate laws provide for cumbersome formalities governing things like
the election and removal of directors, filling vacancies on the board,
holding board and shareholder meetings, keeping minutes of those
meetings, recording board resolutions, and shareholder approval of
major management decisions. Additionally, state laws impose record-keeping requirements,
as well as annual or biennial reporting requirements (and fees), all of
which tend to drive up the cost of operating as a corporation. For
details on annual/biennial reporting requirements and fees, see the the
State Law: Forming a Corporation
section. This is all in addition to the tax and other regulatory
obligations imposed on all small businesses. For more on the tax
obligations of small businesses, see the Tax Obligations of Small Businesses section and the IRS's informational guide, Publication 583 (1/2007), Starting a Business and Keeping Records.
-
- Large, publicly-traded corporations generally have
additional disclosure obligations under federal (and sometimes state)
securities laws. However, a small owner-operated corporation that
issues shares to a small number of people generally will be exempt from
these disclosure requirements. If you contemplate issuing shares to
more than ten people, or to people not actively involved in the
business, you should consult an attorney regarding potential securities
laws obligations.
- Ownership of Assets/Distribution of Profits: The
corporation owns the assets of the business, and shareholders have no
direct financial interest in them. Shareholders own the business
itself, but their direct financial interest is in the shares of stock
that they own. Shares entitle their holder to a portion of corporate
profits, distributed by the company in the form of dividends. The
percentage of profits received as a dividend by a particular
shareholder depends upon that shareholder's proportion of share
ownership. Thus, if you own 50% of the outstanding stock in the
company, you would be entitled to receive 50% of the dividends if and
when the company makes a distribution. Note that corporations do not
have to distribute dividends every year; rather, the board of directors
decides whether to distribute them or to invest proceeds back into the
business.
-
- Shareholders also can sell their shares, unless there
is a restriction on transfer imposed in the articles of incorporation
or a shareholders' agreement (generally an issue with close corporations).
In the case of large, publicly-traded corporations, the price that a
shareholder can get for his/her shares is determined by the price on a
stock market such as the New York Stock Exchange. In the case of smaller
companies that are not publicly-traded, the amount for which a
shareholder can sell her shares is negotiated between the parties to
the transaction, and generally reflects their assessment of the value
of that percentage of the business represented by the selling party's
shares.
- Among the most important assets of any business that
operates a website or blog are its articles, posts, videos, and other
content. For details on who owns what from a copyright perspective, see
the Copyright Ownership of Articles and Posts section.
- Tax Treatment: One of the major (at least perceived) disadvantages of operating as a corporation is "double taxation."
The profits of corporations are normally taxed twice -- once at the corporate level (at the applicable state and federal corporate income tax
rate ), and again on the individual level when profits are distributed
to shareholders as dividends (at the applicable individual income tax
rate - under current law, dividends paid by corporations generally are subject to tax at the same rate as capital gains or 15%). For some corporations, paying reasonable salaries to shareholders who participate in
running the business can help ameliorate the potential burdens of double
taxation to some extent. Shareholders of a corporation cannot deduct business losses
to offset income from other sources. Also, corporations are generally taxed at a relatively high rate (currently about 34% or 35%) on its earned income, which may be higher than applicable indivdidual rates.
-
-
- The corporate form offers full transferability of
shares, which makes it easier for a company to raise capital from
outside investors, and it also makes it somewhat easier for individual
shareholders to "get out" of the business by selling their shares to
other shareholders or outsiders. This may be a major advantage for
those looking to expand the business quickly through outside
investment. However, if you are interested in operating a small
business with others that you know and trust, and not giving up
significant control of the business, the free transferability of shares
may be a disadvantage to adopting the corporate form.
- If you want your corporation to "do business" in states other
than the one in which it is incorporated, you need to register as a
"foreign" corporation doing business in that state. You do not need to
do this simply because your website reaches the residents of other
states. It might be an issue, however, if one of the officers or
employees of the corporation worked (i.e., contributed content to the
website or blog) from another state, and it would likely be required if
your corporation had an office there. State procedures for obtaining
this registration vary, but commonly there is a specific form that you
need to complete, and you will need to submit copies of the articles of incorporation
and a certificate of good standing from your state. There will also be
a registration fee. To get the process started, you should visit the
Secretary of State's website for the state in which you want to
register.
Articles of Incorporation
You must file articles of incorporation (sometimes called a
"certificate of incorporation" or "charter") with your state (usually
with the Secretary of State) and pay a filing fee in order to form a
corporation. The filing fee generally ranges between $70 and $200
depending on the state, but certain states have higher fees -- for
example, Massachusetts ($275) and Texas ($300). See the state pages on forming a corporation for details on state filing fees.
The articles function like the constitution for the corporation.
Ordinarily, the document is short and simple, and you can prepare your
own in a few minutes by filling in the form provided by your state's
filing office, or by drafting your own based on a sample. Generally,
all those people who will be initial shareholders may prepare and sign
the articles, or they can appoint one person to do so. Each state has
its own required version of this document, so the precise requirements
may vary. Below is a list of information commonly required by the
states:
- Company Name: You must include the name of the
corporation, which typically must include "Corporation,"
"Incorporated," "Company," "Limited," or an abbreviation of one of
these words, such as “Inc.” or "Corp." Most states will not allow two
companies to have the same name, nor will they allow your corporation
to adopt a name that is deceptively similar to another company's name.
For more on naming requirements, see the state pages on forming a corporation.
- Name and Address of Registered Agent: Most
states require the name and address (not a P.O. Box) of the
corporation's registered agent in the state of incorporation. The
purpose of the registered agent is to provide a legal address for
service of process in the event of a lawsuit. The registered agent is
also where the state government sends official documents required each
year for tax and legal purposes, such as franchise tax notices and
annual reports. If your corporation incorporates in the same state
where you do business, an officer of the corporation can usually serve
as the registered agent. If your corporation incorporates in a state
other than where it does business, then you will have to hire a
registered agent in the state of incorporation. You can find and hire
registered agent service companies online, and frequently they can
answer questions and provide other assistance with the formation
process.
- Legal Address of the Company: Some states
require that you include the address of the corporation's principal
office (whether or not that address is inside or outside the state of
incorporation). This is distinct from the address of the registered
agent discussed above, although in some circumstances this address
could be the same (i.e., when a corporate officer is serving as the
registered agent).
- Incorporator(s): An incorporator is the person
preparing and filing the formation documents with the state. Most
states require the name and signature of the incorporator or
incorporators to be included in the articles of incorporation. Some
states also require that you include the incorporator’s address.
- Director(s): Some states require that you list
the names and addresses of the initial directors of the corporation in
the articles. If the corporation will have only one shareholder, that
shareholder may also serve as the sole director. When there will be
more than one shareholder, the number of required directors differs
from state to state, and some require more than one director. See the state pages for details on the number of directors required by the fifteen most populous states and the District of Columbia.
In other states, you are not required to identify the
initial directors in the articles of incorporation (although you may do
so if you want). When the initial directors are not named in the
articles, the incorporator or incorporators have the authority to
manage the affairs of the corporation until directors are elected. In
this capacity, they may do whatever is necessary to complete the
organization of the corporation, including calling an organizational
meeting for adopting bylaws and electing directors.
- Business Purpose: Virtually all states require a
statement about the corporation's "business purpose." Most states allow
a general clause stating that the company is formed to engage in "all
lawful business." It is a good idea where permitted to use this general language to
avoid constraining your business activities in the future should the
business move in unanticipated directions.
- Number of Authorized Shares of Stock: You
generally must state in the articles how many shares of stock the
corporation is authorized to issue. Stock is a representation of
ownership of the corporation, and this ownership is divisible based on
the number of shares that the corporation issues. For instance, say the
corporation issues 100 shares -- if you own all 100 shares, then you
own the entire company. If you own 50 shares, then you own half of the
company, and the remaining 50 shares (and 50% ownership interest) can
be divided up among other people (in return for capital contributions,
services, as a gift). Unless shares of stock are designated as
non-voting stock, shares give their owner the ability to vote for the
election of directors in proportion with their ownership interest. (So,
if you own 100% of the stock, you get to elect the directors yourself;
if you own 75% of the stock, you get 75% of the say in who is elected;
and so on).
It is important to keep in mind that, in the articles of incorporation, you designate the number of shares the corporation is authorized to issue -- the corporation is not required to issue
all of those shares right away (or ever). It is common practice for
corporations to hold on to authorized but non-issued shares in order to
add additional owners later or to increase the ownership interest of a
current shareholder. In the articles, it is generally a good idea to
authorize a large number of shares (several thousand), keeping in mind
that the number of authorized shares may be tied to the corporation's
state franchise tax liability. For instance, in Delaware, it is a good
idea for new corporations to authorize 3000 shares, because this is the
maximum number of shares that a corporation can authorize and still
qualify for the minimum $35.00 annual franchise tax.
- Par Value: Some states require that the articles
state the "par value" of the authorized shares. The par value is the
share's minimum stated value -- meaning that a share cannot be sold for
less than its par value. Par value of a share is not the same thing as
its actual value, and the board of directors has discretion to set the
price to be received for stock issued by the corporation without regard
to par value (so long as that value is larger than par value, which it
always is). Most companies set par value at $0.01 or $1 or no par (some
states requiring a designation of par value will accept "no par").
- Preferred Shares: If you plan to authorize
preferred shares of stock in addition to common stock, you must include
information about the preferred shares, along with information about
the voting rights of the respective classes of stock. Preferred shares
typically provide for preferential payments of dividends or
distribution of assets upon termination of the business. Small business
owners often avoid this legal complexity by choosing to authorize only
common stock. This approach is simpler and meets the capitalization
needs of most small businesses. If you plan on creating preferred
shares, you should consult with an attorney before drafting your
articles of incorporation.
You can find the required forms and sample articles of incorporation
for the fifteen most populous U.S. states and the District of Columbia
in the state pages on forming a corporation.
If you want to amend the articles, you can do so by filing
articles of amendment with the same official to whom you submitted the
original articles. There is usually a prepared form for doing this.
Corporate Bylaws
Corporations are required to write and keep a record of their bylaws, but do not have to file them with a state office.
Bylaws are the rules and procedures for how a corporation will
operate and be governed. Although there is no set criteria for bylaws
content, they typically set forth internal rules and procedures for the
corporation, touching on issues like the existence and responsibilities
of corporate offices, the size of the board of directors and the manner
and term of their election, how and when board and shareholder meetings
will be held, who may call meetings, how the board of directors
will function, and to what extent directors and officers will be indemnified against liabilities arising out of performance of their duties. A comprehensive discussion of bylaw content is beyond
the scope of this Guide.
Drafting bylaws can be complex, but there are strategies for
writing satisfactory bylaws without the expense of hiring a lawyer.
FindLaw has posted links to the bylaws of many corporations.
Some of these may prove useful as templates, although many of these
companies have bylaws that are more complex than your small business
would ever need. Findlaw has also posted sample bylaws for a hypothetical Delaware corporation.
These are simple enough, but you would need to adapt them for a
non-Delaware corporation, which could be tricky. For a small fee
(approximately $15), Nolo Press offers a software program, eForm: Corporate Bylaws, which helps you generate bylaws.
The incorporator(s) (i.e., person(s) filing the paperwork) or
initial director(s) (if named in the articles of incorporation)
generally have the authority to adopt a corporation's original bylaws
at the corporation's organizational meeting.
Bylaws may be changed without officially filing amendments.
S Corporation
As an alternative to the ordinary "C corporation" discussed on the Corporation
page, you may carry on your online publishing activities as an "S
corporation." An S corporation has the same basic organizational
structure as a C corporation, with some of the potential tax
advantages of a partnership. A corporation obtains "S" status by filing Form 2553
with the IRS. An S corporation generally does not pay federal income tax at the entity level, except for
tax on certain capital gains and passive income. Instead, the
corporation's profits and losses "pass through" to shareholders, and
profits are taxed at individual rates on each shareholder's Form 1040.
However, an S corporation must file an annual tax return on Form 1120S with the IRS.
S corporations are formed in the same way as C corporations, but with the "S" tax designation filed with the IRS via form 2553
within two-and-a-half months of the date of formation. Federal law imposes certain
requirements on a corporation in order to qualify for "S" status: (1)
the corporation may have no more than 100 shareholders; (2) all
shareholders must be individuals, estates, or certain trusts (i.e., no
corporations, LLCs, or partnerships); (3) no shareholder may be a
nonresident alien; and (4) the corporation may only have one class of
stock. There are additional requirements, which you can learn about by
reading the Instructions for Form 2553.
Your election of "S" status for federal tax purposes does not
guarantee that the profits of your S corporation will not be taxed at
the state level. The District of Columbia, for example, does not
recognize "S" status and subjects the profits of S corporations to the
ordinary state corporate income tax. Other states, such as California
and Illinois, still tax the profits of S corporations, but at much
lower rates than for C corporations. You can find more information
about your state's tax laws in the state pages on forming a corporation.
S corporations generally are preferable to C corporations for
small businesses because they require basically the same amount of
paperwork, but may incur less tax than a C corporation. One drawback of an S
corporation, when compared to a partnership or LLC (which have the same
potential tax benefits as S corporations), comes with the inflexibility
of profit distribution. With an S corporation, profit distributions
must be pro rata to stock ownership, not practical contribution to the success
of the business or any other relevant criteria. Thus, if a person owns
10% of the company, but does 90% of the work, he or she may only be allocated
10% of the profits. (Keep in mind, however, that this person could be
compensated for work through a salary.) Another drawback is that S
corporations are generally subject to the same operating formalities
required of ordinary corporations, and this makes them a somewhat
costlier and more cumbersome option than an LLC or partnership. For
details, see the Corporation section.
Close Corporation
Some states, such as California and Texas, have special provisions
allowing you to create what is known as a "statutory close
corporation." Close corporations generally are formed in the same way
as ordinary corporations, but the articles of incorporation for a close
corporation must state that the corporation shall be considered a
"close corporation" and impose restrictions on transfer of shares of
stock. Close corporations also must have a limited number of
shareholders -- often 35 or 50 shareholders maximum. For state-specific
requirements on forming a close corporation, see the state pages on forming a corporation.
The major reason for forming a close corporation is that it
allows shareholders to operate the business under the terms of a
shareholders' agreement, which can provide for greater flexibility and
informality in managing the affairs of the business (as compared to an
ordinary corporation). Shareholders of a close corporation may agree to
waive certain operating formalities, such as required shareholder or
board meetings. Pursuant to the terms of such an agreement, they can
also dispense with the need to form a board of directors and name
corporate officers, and they (the shareholders) may run the corporation
themselves in a de-centralized fashion. (Incidentally, they may also
agree to a distribution of corporate profits other than proportionally
based on share ownership.) The downside is that a shareholders' agreement that allows shareholders to manage the corporation may make the shareholders liable for acts or omissions for which the corporate directors are usually liable.
Operating as a close
corporation is not popular among incorporators. Negotiating and
drafting an effective shareholders' agreement may be a complex and
costly undertaking, and there is no apparent advantage of operating as
a close corporation rather than an LLC (which also features
decentralized management and limited liability, as well as "pass
through" tax treatment). If you are interested in forming a close
corporation, you should consult with a lawyer.
Double Taxation
The profits of corporations are taxed twice -- once at the entity
level (at the applicable state and federal corporate income tax rate),
and again at the individual level when profits are distributed to
individual owners as dividends (at the applicable individual income tax
rate). Avoiding double taxation is one of the commonly noted advantages
of operating as a sole proprietorship, partnership, or LLC. Nonprofit organizations
that qualify for 501(c)(3) status are exempt from federal (and usually
state) income tax at the entity level, so in a sense they avoid double
taxation as well.
As noted, avoiding double taxation generally is considered
advantageous, but it may not always prove beneficial, depending on your
particular circumstances. Owners of businesses with "pass through" tax
treatment must pay income tax on their share of the net profits of the
business, regardless of the amount of money they actually take out of
the business each year. Thus, even if all profits are reinvested into
the business, the owners of these businesses must pay taxes on their
share of the profits. Shareholders of a corporation, on the other hand,
pay income tax only when those profits are actually distributed to them as dividends. In addition, paying reasonable salaries to shareholders who
participate in the operation of the business can ameliorate the
burden of income tax at the entity level to a certain extent. Additionally, there may be
situations where you as an individual pay income tax at a rate that is
higher than the corporate tax rate.
Note: Tax questions are complex, and the details of such
questions are beyond the scope of this guide. Consult a tax accountant
and an attorney (if necessary) before choosing a business entity based
on tax issues.
Corporate Records
In addition to the two major "constitutional" documents (the articles of incorporation and the bylaws),
corporations are required to keep copies of a number of other records
relating to the the organization, finances, and ownership of the
business.
State record-keeping requirements vary. You can find links to your State's specific record-keeping requirements in the State Law: Forming a Corporation
section of this Guide. However, as a matter of best practices you
should keep copies of at least the following documents in the
corporation's principal office (where it is operating on a day-to-day
basis) and on file with the corporation's registered agent (this latter
step is applicable only if the corporation is incorporated in a state
other than the state in which it does business):
- the articles of incorporation and any amendments;
- the corporation's bylaws and any older versions used in the three most recent years;
- a shareholders' agreement or close corporation agreement, if one exists;
- minutes from shareholders' meetings for the three most recent years;
- records of all actions taken by shareholders without a meeting for the three most recent years;
- minutes from board of directors meetings for the three most recent years;
- a list of the full names of all shareholders and their respective ownership interests;
- a stock transfer ledger;
- a list of the full names and last known addresses of all past and present directors;
- a list of the full names and last known addresses of all past and present officers;
- financial records, including federal, state, and local tax returns and reports, for the three most recent years;
- all communications made to shareholders over the three most recent years;
- annual or biennial reports or statements of information filed with the State for the three most recent years;
- resolutions adopted by the board of directors in the three
most recent years with respect to one or more classes or series of
shares and fixing their relative rights, preferences, and limitations,
if shares issued pursuant to those resolutions are outstanding;
- resolutions adopted by the board of directors creating one or more classes or series of shares; and
- any other documents filed with the State.
These requirements are in addition to those required for all small
businesses for tax purposes. For more on the tax obligations of small
businesses, see the Tax Obligations of Small Businesses section and the IRS's informational guide, Publication 583 (1/2007), Starting a Business and Keeping Records.